Anime Girl Desperation Official Forum

Announcements, FAQs, and Other Important Stuff => Suggestion Bin/Comments/Complaints => Topic started by: D_guy10 on November 12, 2008, 10:33:44 PM

Title: Alleged "Dead Threads"
Post by: D_guy10 on November 12, 2008, 10:33:44 PM
 I was wondering why posting in a thread that's 2+ months old is frowned upon. If an "old" thread is bumped up because somebody posted their opinion then other members (some whom already have a post count higher than 10) see it and add their own comments, well that creates some discussion. Which is the whole point of a message board and something that's always been encouraged here.

Now I get the point of keeping new members (leechers) from spamming up the board reviving old threads so they can take a look at the goods, but keeping in mind that the site isn't that old, how old must a thread be in order to be considered it defunct or "tapped out" as it may be?

I say this out of concern since I'd hate to see potential productive members get shunned in their early stages because the rules might be taken a bit too seriously.
Title: Re: Alleged "Dead Threads"
Post by: FallenStar on November 12, 2008, 10:41:57 PM
As I've already indicated in another topic, a thread that is two months old without any new post is considered a "dead" thread.  Thus, unless something "odd" happens, most of those threads will be closed without fail.

Title: Re: Alleged "Dead Threads"
Post by: D_guy10 on November 12, 2008, 10:56:22 PM
That might limit the discussion field a little bit, but alright.
Title: Re: Alleged "Dead Threads"
Post by: packrat on November 13, 2008, 10:20:57 PM
But if you keep letting threads die like that people will just make duplicates.  And once the duplicate dies anther one will be made.  Before long you'l have about 5 or 6 threads that all have the same subject with more than half of them closed do to being too old.  Merging threads helps a bit, but you have to search for the thread to merge with before you can merge them. 

My point is, maybe you should extend the deadline a bit.  this forum isn't busy enough to have a 2-month limit on threads.  As for the leechers who bump threads for the sake of geting to the goodies, delete their post and send them a warning or something.  If they do it continuously then ban them.  Seriously, we just need to be harder on the newbs is all.